The Murderous Tale of Tragedy Spring and the Mormon Emigrant Trail

Written by Rick Rockwell• November 26, 2022• 5:17 pm• Gold Rush, History and Mystery, Regional Park, Roadside Attraction
Last Updated on: August 12, 2026
Tragedy Spring looks like a quiet stop in the high Sierra today, but its name comes from one of the darker stories tied to the Mormon Emigrant Trail. In 1848, three Mormon Battalion veterans — Daniel Browett, Ezra Hela Allen, and Henderson Cox — rode ahead of their company to scout a wagon route across the Sierra Nevada. They never returned.
Weeks later, their companions found signs of a violent struggle near a spring in the forest: a campfire, bloody arrows, blood-stained rocks, and a grave holding the bodies of the three missing men. The company buried them again, carved their names into a tree, and gave the place the name it still carries: Tragedy Spring.
Today, Tragedy Spring is a small historic site and picnic area off Highway 88 near Silver Lake. It is easy to miss if you are speeding toward Carson Pass or Kirkwood, but it is one of the most meaningful roadside history stops along this old emigrant corridor.






